- Who is this for?
- Freight brokers, freight forwarders, brokerage managers, billing and management control teams in forwarding companies
- Question addressed
- Audit a subcontracted carrier’s invoice by reconciling it with the rate confirmation and the CMR before paying the carrier and billing the shipper.
Short answer
For a freight broker or freight forwarder, auditing a subcontracted carrier’s invoice means reconciling it with two documents already in the brokerage file: the rate confirmation, which sets the agreed price and conditions, and the signed CMR consignment note, which records what was actually performed. Every invoice line must trace back to one or the other; a line that traces back to neither is a discrepancy to qualify, not an error to correct on the spot. The broker then decides to accept, dispute or request a document, and keeps that decision in the file and in the carrier’s history.
Key takeaways
- Every line on the carrier’s invoice is grounded either in the rate confirmation or in an execution document; otherwise it is a discrepancy.
- Six families of discrepancies cover almost every case, and for each one a specific document settles the question.
- The audit always follows the same order: match, verify the issuer, compare the price, read the CMR, examine accessorial lines, qualify, decide.
- The order between paying the carrier and billing the shipper is a rule to choose and write down, not a habit.
- A discrepancy ends with a recorded decision: accept, dispute or request a document, with its effect on the carrier’s history.
- The signed contract and the applicable standard contract set the framework; no universal dispute deadline is asserted here.
Three documents, three different questions
The rate confirmation (also called a load confirmation) is the document by which a freight broker assigns a shipment to a subcontracted carrier, fixing the price, the conditions and the services expected. The CMR consignment note, used for international road carriage and often reused domestically, is signed at loading and at delivery: it records quantities handed over, reservations and, depending on practice, arrival and departure times. The carrier’s invoice states what the carrier is asking for; it replaces neither of the other two.
Reconciliation comes down to one rule: every invoice line must be grounded either in the rate confirmation, for the agreed price and services, or in the CMR or another execution document, for what was actually done and recorded. A line that is grounded in neither is not necessarily wrong, but it cannot be paid on the strength of the invoice alone. French transport law adds that the execution document signed at the loading and unloading sites is taken as proof of how the contract was performed, unless the contrary is shown.
| Document | Question it answers | What you read in it | What it does not prove |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rate confirmation | What was agreed? | Price, conditions, accessorial services, fuel rule, pallet rule | That the shipment went as planned |
| Signed CMR | What happened? | Quantities delivered, reservations, signatures, sometimes times | The agreed price |
| Signed waiting-time or service record | How long, which unplanned services? | Arrival and departure times, accessorial services performed | That the service had an agreed rate |
| Carrier invoice | What is the carrier asking for? | Lines, amounts, file references | That a line is owed |
Typical discrepancies and the document that settles them
Most discrepancies found on a carrier’s invoice fall into six families. For each, one specific document settles the question, and the possible decision depends on what that document contains or fails to contain. The point of the grid is to move away from a debate about judgement: nobody argues about the carrier’s good faith, the question is which document grounds the line.
| Discrepancy | Document that settles it | Possible decision |
|---|---|---|
| Price differs from the rate confirmation | Accepted confirmation, amendment or later written exchange | Pay the confirmed price; accept the difference only if an amendment or written exchange supports it |
| Unplanned waiting or detention charges | Waiting record signed at loading or delivery, waiting rule in the confirmation | Accept if the time is signed and the overrun is not the carrier’s fault; request the document otherwise |
| Fuel surcharge applied differently | Clause or index in the confirmation, fuel costs shown on the invoice | Recalculate under the clause; dispute the calculation method, not the principle of adjustment |
| Pallets not exchanged | Pallet note on the CMR or exchange slip, pallet rule in the confirmation | Charge or deduct under the agreed rule; with no note, request the document before any deduction |
| Partial delivery or reservations | Signed CMR with specific reservations, incident report | Pay for the carriage performed; handle the damage in a separate file, with no set-off against the price |
| Duplicate invoice | Invoice number, file reference, history of invoices received | Reject the second one and record the recurrence in the carrier’s history |
Audit sequence when the invoice arrives
The audit benefits from always following the same order, because the order guards against two mistakes: disputing an amount that has not first been matched to the right file, and paying an accessorial line before reading the CMR. Its value shows on incomplete files, where a document is missing or contradicts the invoice; that is where it prevents payment on the strength of the document received alone.
- 01Match
Identify the brokerage file the invoice refers to from references, dates and locations, and check that no invoice has already been received for that file.
- 02Verify the issuer
Check that the company name, registration number and bank details match the confirmed carrier and its file; a change of bank details is verified through a channel other than the email announcing it.
- 03Compare the main line
Reconcile the invoiced carriage price with the price in the rate confirmation and any amendments.
- 04Read the CMR
Note quantities, reservations, partial delivery, pallet notes and, where present, times; record what was actually done.
- 05Examine each accessorial line
For waiting time, fuel, pallets or any other accessorial service, identify the confirmation clause and the execution document that ground it.
- 06Qualify each discrepancy
Classify each difference in the grid of typical discrepancies and note the missing or contradictory document.
- 07Decide and record
Accept, dispute or request a document, then record the decision, its rationale and its date in the file.
In what order to bill the shipper and pay the carrier
The margin on a brokerage file is the difference between what the shipper pays and what the carrier is paid. Until the carrier side has been reconciled, that margin is only a hypothesis: a waiting charge accepted after the fact, a recalculated fuel surcharge or an unexchanged pallet all change it. Two ordering rules exist and each can be defended; what cannot be defended is the absence of a written rule.
The first rule secures the carrier side before billing the shipper: the shipper’s invoice goes out once the carrier’s invoice has been reconciled, so that grounded accessorial charges are passed on in a single invoice, under the conditions set in the shipper contract. The second rule bills the shipper as soon as the CMR is signed and deals with the carrier’s invoice afterwards: cash comes in earlier, at the cost of a supplementary invoice or a credit note if a grounded discrepancy appears. The choice depends on the payment terms agreed on each side and on how often discrepancies actually occur per carrier.
| Rule | What it secures | What it costs | Condition for keeping it |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reconcile the carrier before billing the shipper | The margin and accessorial charges passed on in one invoice | A billing delay if the carrier’s invoice is late | An internal cut-off date after which you bill anyway |
| Bill the shipper on the CMR, reconcile afterwards | Cash flow and the terms agreed with the shipper | Supplementary invoices or credit notes, sometimes refused | A shipper contract that allows accessorial charges to be rebilled |
| Mixed rule by carrier or by lane | Adaptation to the level of trust observed | A rule that must be kept up to date | A discrepancy history per carrier |
What to do with a discrepancy: accept, dispute, request a document
A discrepancy has only three outcomes. Accept: the line is grounded, or the difference is too small to justify an exchange, and the decision is recorded with its rationale. Dispute: the line is grounded neither in the confirmation nor in an execution document, and the dispute names the line, the amount, the document expected and the file reference. Request a document: the line is plausible but the document is missing; the request is dated and payment of that line waits, without holding up the rest of the invoice if the contract allows it.
The contractual framework matters. In France, when subcontracting is regular and significant, the standard contract for road haulage performed by subcontractors (annex IX of the Code des transports) governs the relationship in the absence of a written agreement; it excludes spot operations, for which the general standard contract applies by default. In the version consulted, it provides for a monthly summary invoice referring to the agreed prices and the services actually performed, payment within a period that may not exceed thirty days from issue, and a prohibition on unilateral set-off. It sets no deadline for disputing an invoice: that point comes from the signed contract.
- The decision (accepted, disputed, document requested) with its date and author.
- The document that grounded the decision, or the document expected and the recipient of the request.
- The amount at stake and its effect on the file’s margin.
- The carrier’s response and the date the discrepancy was closed.
- The signal kept for the carrier’s history: grounded discrepancy accepted, ungrounded discrepancy, document supplied on request, duplicate invoice.
What Vigilo does with the carrier’s invoice
Vigilo attaches the incoming invoice to the brokerage file where the rate confirmation and the signed CMR it has already attached are held, then compares line by line: carriage price against the confirmation, accessorial lines against clauses and execution documents, references against invoices already received to spot a duplicate. Each discrepancy is highlighted with the documents that ground it or that are missing, under the broker’s rules.
The decision file is prepared: discrepancy, document, amount, effect on the margin and, where a document is missing, the request ready to go to the carrier. The broker accepts, disputes or requests the document; Vigilo keeps the decision, its rationale and the response, and the discrepancy feeds the carrier’s score according to the signals agreed with the broker. A discrepancy outside the configured rules, an invoice with no identifiable file or an issuer whose details do not match goes back to a person with the context already assembled.
Putting discrepancies to work on the next load
Invoice-by-invoice auditing protects the margin on one file; the discrepancy history protects the files that follow. A carrier whose invoices match the confirmation, who attaches the waiting record without being asked and who has never invoiced twice deserves different treatment from one whose every invoice calls for a dispute. That difference should be visible when choosing the carrier and setting the price, not only when paying.
Three concrete uses. At assignment, the share of ungrounded discrepancies per carrier enters the choice, alongside document validity and CMR return. When quoting the shipper, the accessorial charges actually observed on a lane, recurring waiting at a given site or pallets rarely exchanged at a given delivery point, help refine the price offered. At audit time, a carrier with no discrepancy over a given period may qualify for a lighter audit, defined in writing and reviewed at the first anomaly.
Frequently asked questions
Direct answers
Should a carrier invoice be paid when only one line is disputed?
It depends on the signed contract and the applicable standard contract. A common practice is to pay the undisputed part and handle the disputed line separately, in writing, with the document expected. The French standard contracts consulted prohibit withholding an alleged damage against the carriage price in any case.
What if the carrier invoices waiting time that does not appear on the CMR?
Request the waiting record signed at the loading or unloading site, which records the vehicle’s arrival and departure times. French transport law treats that document as proof of performance unless the contrary is shown. Without it, the line remains ungrounded and can be disputed by naming exactly what is expected.
Is there a legal deadline for disputing a subcontracted carrier’s invoice?
The French subcontracting standard contract, in the version consulted on Légifrance, sets no deadline for disputing an invoice. Any deadline comes from the contract signed between the broker and the carrier or from the broker’s purchasing terms. Check it before relying on it or holding the carrier to it.
How does Vigilo audit a subcontracted carrier’s invoice?
Vigilo attaches the invoice to the brokerage file, compares it with the rate confirmation and the signed CMR already held there, highlights each discrepancy with the documents, prepares the decision file and keeps the decision taken. The discrepancy feeds the carrier’s score; accepting or disputing remains the broker’s choice.
Should the shipper’s invoice wait for the carrier’s invoice?
Not necessarily, but a written rule is needed. Billing after reconciliation secures the margin and avoids supplementary invoices; billing on the CMR helps cash flow but assumes the shipper contract allows accessorial charges to be rebilled. A mixed rule per carrier is workable if the discrepancy history is maintained.
Sources
- French Code des transports, annex IX: standard contract for public road haulage performed by subcontractorsLégifrance, version in force since 1 October 2019, consulted on 12 October 2026. Articles 1.1 and 1.3 (regular and significant subcontracting, exclusion of spot operations), 5.10 (unplanned accessorial services), 12.1 (monthly summary invoice), 13.1 (payment within a period not exceeding thirty days), 13.4 (prohibition of unilateral set-off).
- French Code des transports, article L3222-5: execution record, loading and unloading timesLégifrance, version in force since 1 December 2010, consulted on 12 October 2026. Signed record of arrival and departure times and accessorial services; it is taken as proof of how the contract was performed unless the contrary is shown.
- French Code des transports, article L3222-1: price adjustment for fuel costsLégifrance, version in force since 1 January 2023, consulted on 12 October 2026. Automatic adjustment of the agreed price and disclosure of propulsion energy costs on the invoice.
- French Code des transports, annex II: general standard contract for public road haulageLégifrance, version in force since 1 September 2021, consulted on 12 October 2026. Articles 11.3 (additional remuneration for vehicle immobilisation), 18.2 (accessorial services paid at the agreed price), 19.2 (prohibition of unilateral set-off).
- French Code des transports, articles L1432-2 to L1432-4: content of the carriage contract and default application of standard contractsLégifrance, consulted on 12 October 2026. In the absence of a written agreement, the parties’ relationship is governed by default by the standard contracts.